The Wrong Catch by C.R. Jane

My rating: 5 of 5 stars

I was his stalker.

He was my religion.

And somewhere between the lies and the worship,

we fell in love.

Everyone warned me that love could ruin you.

They just never said it would feel this good while it burned.

Matty Adler is the University of Tennessee’s golden boy—star tight end, campus legend, the kind of man girls write their names next to in notebooks.

I should know.

Mine’s filled with his.

I used to watch him from my car.

Follow his schedule.

Trace his smile like it was a prayer.

He was the reason I chose this school. The reason I started breathing again.

And then one day, he looked up and saw me.

Now he’s caught me.

Now he says he loves me, too.

He was never supposed to know my secret.

But love like ours doesn’t play fair. It devours. It traps. It destroys.

And maybe that’s what we both wanted all along.

Because maybe…I was never the wrong choice.

Maybe I was his only one.

*Note: Matty Adler is a morally grey antihero who is obsessed with his girl and will do anything to keep her. This is a darker football romance.

A Playbook on Obsession

The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: ❤️💚💙🩷💛
Chemistry: 🧪🧪🧪🧪🧪
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙📔
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌍🌍
Character development: 🤓😟🤯😎🥰
Narration: 🎙🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration Type: Duet Narration

Character Backgrounds and Plot Overview

At fourteen, Ophelia sat outside her therapist’s office listening to her parents discuss how disturbed they were by her behavior. Her fixation on a boy had escalated into something they could no longer ignore. She was diagnosed with obsessive love disorder, a blend of borderline personality disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, and attachment disorder. Her symptoms had intensified, and her parents believed she needed a more structured environment. Their disappointment only deepened her loneliness, especially after she was caught with a hoodie she had stolen from Nico at school. She hated herself for being the kind of girl who did things like that, and she knew the boy she obsessed over would never return her feelings. She spent the next two years in a psychiatric institution.

Returning home did not make life easier. Ophelia drifted through her days without purpose or direction. When it came time to apply for college, she chose a few local two-year programs. Everything changed when an advertisement for the University of Tennessee appeared on her screen. The moment she saw Matthew Adler, star football player, she felt a spark of purpose. She applied immediately. For the first time in years, she felt ambition and direction.

Once accepted, Ophelia began researching Matthew. She memorized his address and walked past his house on her first day at school. She watched him laugh with neighbors and disappear down the street with friends. Her dorm was far from his neighborhood, but she knew how to blend in and remain unnoticed. His voice, his movements, and even the way he carried himself became imprinted in her mind.

Highlights

I usually avoid stories where the heroine is the stalker. I prefer the anti-hero to carry the darker traits while the heroine remains grounded. Surprisingly, I liked Ophelia from the beginning. Her behavior was not written off as quirky or exaggerated. She had real diagnoses, real struggles, and a deep longing to be loved, especially since her parents had already given up on her. Her instability felt rooted in pain rather than shock value.

I also loved that Matty had friends who were stalkers themselves. Their history made him cautious around Ophelia, which added a believable layer to his hesitation. His friends had stalked their girlfriends before getting together, so Matty recognized the signs. He noticed Ophelia early on but chose not to approach her. Over time, he grew used to her presence and even looked for her car each day. He wondered if he would miss her if she stopped showing up. He liked that she watched quietly instead of throwing herself at him like other girls.

The best part was how hard Matty fell for her. He had no idea she was the girl watching him from afar, yet he became obsessed with her in his own way. He wanted to know how she looked when she slept. He imagined slipping notes under her door. He even fantasized about tracking her phone so he would always know where she was. Without realizing it, he became the stalker in the relationship.

Limitations

One limitation of The Wrong Catch is its uneven pacing. The beginning is gripping and emotionally charged, but the middle section lingers too long on repetitive internal conflict. Listeners who prefer tighter plotting or more external action may find certain scenes slow.

Another drawback is the character development. While the main couple is compelling, their emotional growth sometimes feels rushed or inconsistent. The push and pull dynamic leans heavily on miscommunication rather than natural conflict, which can be frustrating. Some listeners may find it difficult to fully connect with their choices or believe in the depth of their transformation.

Narration and Performance

The audiobook is told in dual points of view with duet narration by Lucas Webley and Alexis Page. Lucas Page has a deep voice that I like, he does sound a bit older that Matty, since Matty is supposed to be in college and Lucas sounds like he is in his 30’s or 40’s. Though that didn’t bother me much. Alexis Page, on the other hand, is excellent. She has a youthful, expressive tone that fits Ophelia perfectly.

The production includes a unique detail I had never heard before. When Ophelia speaks at one point when she is just getting to know Matty, you can hear her breathing heavily and her breath catching. It makes her sound nervous and overwhelmed by her own thoughts. This small choice adds authenticity to her mental health struggles and highlights how unfamiliar she is with being the focus of someone’s affection.

Final Thoughts

The Wrong Catch blends obsession, vulnerability, and romance in a way that feels both unsettling and strangely tender. Ophelia’s mental health challenges are portrayed with more depth than I expected, and Matty’s shift from wary observer to full blown obsessive adds an intriguing reversal to the usual stalker romance dynamic. The pacing and character development are not perfect, but the emotional tension and the unusual relationship dynamic make the story memorable. If you enjoy romances that lean into psychological complexity and morally gray behavior, this audiobook delivers a compelling and unconventional experience.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Twitter|BookBub



View all my reviews