The Fallen Ones: A Dark Masked Men Romance by K.G. Reuss

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Three masked men. One night. One room. One goal. Falling in love is out of the question. Watching my mother die for love only made me want it that much less.

When things become too serious with my boyfriend in college, I know it’s time to step back.

The only problem is, he doesn’t feel the same.

His brand of love is possessive. Fierce. Terrifying.

And he’s not afraid to enlist my best friend and my former stepbrother to help him get me back.

The plan? A party at Satan’s Hollow, an elite frat on the Holloway University campus where the hookups are plenty and secrets are hidden behind the masks we wear.

The goal? Get me the same key to the room they have and then…Well, let’s just say that vow I took won’t last for long because my ex, my best friend, and my former stepbrother are making it their mission to change my mind.

Together. No matter the cost.

The Fallen Ones

Three Men, One Haunted Heart, and a Whole Lot of Trouble

The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: 💙💛💚💜
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Chemistry: 🧪🧪🧪🧪🧪
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📔
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌏
Character development: 😋🙂😁
Narrator(s): 🎙🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration type: Duet Narration – Full Cast

Character Backgrounds and Plot Summary

The Fallen Ones by K.G. Reuss and J.A. Roles is a dark, complicated romance centered on Lily and three men who each have a very different connection to her: her ex-boyfriend Jace, her longtime best friend Caleb, and her former stepbrother Damien.

Lily’s fear of intimacy is rooted in her mother’s history. Her mother repeatedly fell in love with men who ultimately failed to appreciate her, and after discovering that her husband had cheated on her, she died by suicide when Lily was sixteen. That experience leaves Lily convinced that falling in love is dangerous, and she has spent years keeping people at a distance.

Jace managed to get closer than anyone else. They dated for nine months, and he genuinely loved her, but eventually he became frustrated with waiting for Lily to overcome her fear of intimacy. She ultimately ended their relationship. Instead of handling the breakup maturely, Jace begins perpetuating rumors about sleeping with other girls. When Lily confronts him, his response that whatever happens is her fault made me particularly angry with him.

Things become even more complicated when Jace and Caleb secretly arrange for Lily to attend a Halloween costume party where they intend to share her without her knowledge. Damien overhears their plan and blackmails his way into the arrangement, threatening to show Lily a video he recorded. His involvement is especially loaded because he already despises Jace after Jace’s mother became involved with Damien’s father, destroying both families and ultimately contributing to Lily leaving his home.

Meanwhile, Lily is struggling with her attraction to all three men, creating a relationship dynamic filled with betrayal, jealousy, manipulation, and some very questionable decisions.

Highlights and Limitations

The strongest part of the story for me was the sheer amount of emotional baggage between these characters. None of the relationships exist in a vacuum. Jace and Damien’s hostility comes from their families’ history, while Lily’s inability to trust intimacy is directly connected to watching her mother’s relationships end so badly. That gives the central conflict more weight than simply having three attractive men competing for one woman.

I also found the Halloween party setup to be one of the most disturbing and memorable plot developments. Knowing that Jace and Caleb were making plans behind Lily’s back while she believed she was simply going to a party completely changed how I viewed their relationships with her.

That said, I struggled with Lily. I found her naive, overly trusting, and frequently frustrating. Her fear of intimacy was understandable given what happened to her mother, but I sometimes had difficulty connecting her trauma to some of her choices. In particular, her desire to be forced into intimacy felt contradictory to the very fears the story established. Plus, she went on a date with a guy after her best friend told her there were rumors the guy raped some girls. It is one thing to want consensual non-consent, but another to be too stupid to live and date a guy like that.

Jace was another character I had a hard time forgiving. I could understand being hurt after Lily ended their relationship, especially after he had spent nine months waiting for her but deliberately spreading rumors and then blaming Lily when she confronted him crossed a line for me. Surprisingly I liked Damien the best. He had a lot of anger in him stemming from his daddy issues, but his inner commentary showed a tender heart in the ways he felt for Lily.

Narration

The audiobook features Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden, Corvin King, and Jacob Morgan, which is a seriously strong cast for this type of dark romance. Each narrator brings a different quality to the male characters, helping distinguish the personalities and emotional tones rather than making the multiple male perspectives blur together.

Lucy Rivers does a good job portraying Lily’s uncertainty and emotional vulnerability, particularly when Lily is wrestling with her feelings and trying to understand why she is attracted to these three very different men. Joe Arden brings the intensity expected from Jace, while Corvin King and Jacob Morgan add their own distinct energy to Damien and Caleb.

What worked best for me was how the narration supported the darker atmosphere. The performances made the jealousy, anger, attraction, and manipulation feel much more immediate than they might have on the page. It doesn’t hurt that these are three of my favorite male narrators, with awesome voices.

Final Opinion

This was definitely not an easy romance for me to love. I went into it expecting to become invested in Lily, but I actually found myself frustrated with her quite often, especially during the beginning. Her choices sometimes left me scratching my head, and several of the men’s actions made them equally difficult to root for.

Still, I appreciated that the story made me react strongly. The complicated history between the characters, the secrets surrounding the Halloween party, Jace’s behavior after the breakup, and Lily’s struggle with the legacy of her mother’s relationships gave me plenty to think about.

For readers who enjoy dark romance with morally questionable characters, complicated relationships, possessiveness, betrayal, and a heroine caught between three very different men, The Fallen Ones offers plenty of material to sink into. It pushed my comfort zone in places, and I definitely did not agree with every character’s decision, but I can’t say the story was forgettable. If anything, I found myself having strong opinions about these characters long after particular scenes ended, which is usually a sign that a book managed to get under my skin.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Pinterest|BookBub



View all my reviews