Breakthrough by Michael C. Grumley

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Deep in the Caribbean ocean, a nuclear submarine is forced to suddenly abort its mission under mysterious circumstances. Strange facts begin to emerge that lead naval investigator John Clay to a small group of marine biologists who are quietly on the verge of making history. Alison Shaw and her team are preparing to translate the first two-way conversation with another animal species, but they are about to discover much more than they ever expected. When a mysterious object is found on the ocean floor and an unknown group suddenly becomes interested in her work, Alison learns that Clay may be the only person she can really trust. Together they find themselves embroiled in a desperate attempt to stop a catastrophe that spans the Atlantic Ocean and reaches all the way to Antarctica.

Breakthrough

This Book Made Me Root for a Dolphin Named Dirk

The following ratings are out of 5:
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌏
Character development: 😋😀🤯😎
Narration: 🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration type: Solo Narration

Main Characters and Plot Overview

This one hooked me faster than I expected. Alison Shaw is a marine biologist who has spent years working with two dolphins, Dirk and Sally, at the Miami aquarium, trying to crack real two-way communication using an AI system called IMIS. When the words “Hello,” “Yes,” and “No” actually appear on the monitor in response to the dolphins, I felt the same jolt of disbelief the whole team does in that scene.

On the other side of the story is John Clay, a naval investigator pulled into a strange case when the submarine Alabama veers fifteen miles off course with no explainable cause. Clay and his friend Steve Caesare start chasing down what looks like a tech glitch and end up finding a massive glowing ring on the ocean floor instead. These two threads collide when Frank Dubois, hungry for funding, invites the Navy into Alison’s lab. She does not trust them, and honestly, I did not blame her, given what we learn about her past run in with the military. Watching her let her guard down around Clay felt earned rather than rushed. Though this isn’t a romance, there are many characters in this story.

Highlights and Limitations

The dolphin storyline is what sold me on this book. The scene where Alison asks the team to try “Food Yes” and Dirk actually responds is such a small moment on paper, but Grumley builds the tension around it so well that I found myself grinning. I also loved the Antarctica subplot with Kathryn Lokke fighting to get anyone in Washington to take her seismic data seriously. Her confrontation with National Security Advisor Stevas, who dismisses her warnings despite the risk of a catastrophic tsunami, made me want to reach through the speaker and shake him.

Where the book stumbles a little is pacing in the middle third. There is a stretch involving the missing Triton submersible and satellite interference that felt more like table setting than story, and I found my attention drifting during some of the more technical exposition about magnetic readings and signal loss. I also wished the mysterious figure Palin had gotten more development before the ending pushed the plot into full alien territory. His appearance out of nowhere to save a dying man is such a big swing that it needed a little more grounding to really land for me.

Narration

Scott Brick is exactly the right choice for this kind of techno thriller. He gives Clay a steady, clipped military cadence that fits his role, and he shifts into something warmer and more curious for Alison’s chapters, and this book is told from other points of view as well, his changing voice and accents helped me track the alternating perspectives without ever feeling lost. His pacing during the storm sequence on the Pathfinder, when the anchor chain snaps and the ship lurches through the waves, had my pulse actually going. He also handles the large ensemble cast well. Frank Dubois sounds appropriately self important, Borger sounds like the kind of guy who lives on energy drinks and bad puns, and Kathryn Lokke comes across as sharp and no nonsense without ever tipping into caricature.

Final Thoughts

I went into this expecting a fun animal communication story and came out with a full-blown government conspiracy thriller with aliens, seismic disasters, and a slow burn trust building friendship between two well drawn leads. I did not expect to care this much about a pair of fictional dolphins, but by the time they were left behind on the Pathfinder during the evacuation, I was genuinely anxious for them. If you like Michael Crichton or Clive Cussler and do not mind a story that asks you to accept some fairly big scientific leaps, I think you will have a great time with this one. I am already lining up the next book in the series because I need to know what happens to Dirk and Sally, and honestly, to Clay and Alison too.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Pinterest|BookBub




View all my reviews