Deserving Henley by Susan Stoker

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Years of adversity have molded Henley McClure into the attentive, conscientious psychologist she is today. She lives for her daughter, Jasna, and her work at The Refuge, an exclusive retreat for victims of PTSD. Her life is fulfilling…if a little lonely. But the only man who’s captured her interest, the most standoffish of the mountain retreat’s seven owners, lives in self-imposed isolation. It will take a little vulnerability on her own part, a dead car battery, and the surprising help of her daughter to break through Finn’s defenses.

His Coast Guard career ended in a tragedy that ground Finn “Tonka” Matlick’s life to a halt. For years, his only solace has been the animals he tends to at The Refuge…and admiring Henley from afar. He had no plans to risk potential heartache ever again, until an incident at the retreat had him clinging to Henley like the broken man he is. The kind, patient therapist and her sweet, thoughtful daughter may be the only ones capable of putting him back together.

As Finn slowly heals, and he and Henley grow ever closer, someone is watching. Waiting. Planning. Evil in the making who ultimately wants to watch the world burn, one victim at a time. And they’ll start by targeting one of the people Finn loves most.

Deserving Henley

Love, Loyalty, and Learning to Trust Again

The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: 💙💛💚❤️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Chemistry: 🧪🧪🧪🧪
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌏
Character development: 😋🙂😁😛
Narrator(s): 🎙🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration type: Dual Narration

Character Backgrounds and Plot Summary

Henley McClure is the psychologist at The Refuge, a retreat dedicated to helping people recover from PTSD and trauma. She is compassionate, intelligent, and deeply devoted to her young daughter, Jasna. While Henley has built a fulfilling life centered around helping others, there is still an undercurrent of loneliness. For years, she has been quietly attracted to Finn “Tonka” Matlick, one of The Refuge’s owners.

Finn is easily the most withdrawn member of the group. A former Coast Guard rescue swimmer, he carries crushing guilt and unresolved trauma from a mission that ended in tragedy. Rather than seeking comfort from others, he isolates himself with the animals he cares for at the retreat. He prefers predictable routines and keeps everyone at arm’s length.

A dead car battery, childcare complications, and Jasna’s natural curiosity create opportunities for Henley and Finn to spend time together outside of work. Jasna becomes an unexpected bridge between them, especially as she develops a sweet bond with Finn through the animals. As Finn slowly lowers his defenses and begins imagining a future beyond survival, a dangerous predator lurking in the background shifts his attention toward those Finn has come to love.

Highlights and Limitations

What stood out most to me was Finn’s emotional journey. Susan Stoker did not rush his healing or magically erase years of trauma once he fell in love. Finn struggles with guilt, avoidance, and the fear of causing pain to others. Watching him take small steps forward felt authentic. One of my favorite aspects was how Jasna brought out a gentler side of him. Their interactions with the animals were genuinely heartwarming and often provided much needed moments of lightness.

Henley was equally impressive. She understood trauma professionally, but she also carried scars of her own. I appreciated that she respected Finn’s boundaries while still encouraging him to reconnect with life. She never tried to “fix” him. Instead, she offered patience, consistency, and understanding.

The suspense element was particularly unsettling because readers are given glimpses into the villain’s mindset. Knowing danger is approaching while Henley, Finn, and Jasna are building their fragile happiness creates a steady sense of dread. The threat involving someone Finn deeply cares about significantly raised the emotional stakes.

I have to admit that this villain really disturbed me, he wanted to be one of the worst serial killers the country had ever seen and like many serial killers, he started with animals. I didn’t like the fact that he mentioned torturing a dog for a week before killing it and the fact that his next victim is a donkey he had been eyeing for a while. I have been loving Donkey the Donkey on TikTok lately, so I just didn’t want to have that image in my head.

If I had one criticism, it would be that the pacing occasionally leaned more heavily into the emotional healing and domestic moments before the suspense fully escalated. Readers looking for nonstop action from beginning to end may find the first half slower than some of Stoker’s other books. However, I felt the quieter moments were necessary to establish the emotional investment that made the later danger so effective.

Narration

The three narrators complemented one another beautifully.

Ramona Master captured Henley’s warmth, competence, and vulnerability. She conveyed Henley’s maternal instincts without making her sound overly sentimental and handled the emotional scenes with sincerity.

Aaron Shedlock gave Finn the gruff, guarded tone I expected from a man carrying so much pain. He excelled during Finn’s introspective moments, allowing listeners to hear both his strength and his uncertainty.

Teddy Hamilton’s contributions added variety and polish to the production. Together, the cast created an engaging listening experience that helped distinguish the characters and maintained momentum throughout the story.

The use of multiple narrators enhanced the emotional depth of the audiobook and made the relationships feel more immediate.

Final Opinion

Deserving Henley delivered exactly what I have come to expect from Susan Stoker: a blend of romance, suspense, and characters who genuinely deserve their happy ending. Finn’s transformation from isolated caretaker to devoted partner and protector was deeply satisfying, and Jasna absolutely stole scenes without overshadowing the romance. Her relationship with Finn was just as meaningful as the love story developing between Finn and Henley.

This audiobook balanced tenderness with tension, explored the long shadow trauma can cast over a person’s life, and reminded listeners that healing often happens through connection rather than grand gestures. It was emotional, suspenseful, and incredibly easy to root for. If you enjoy romantic suspense featuring damaged heroes, capable heroines, found family, and a child character who adds heart instead of frustration, this is a wonderful addition to The Refuge series.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Pinterest|BookBub



View all my reviews