Mr. Heartbreaker by Piper Rayne

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I made a deal with my brother a long time ago to never date his teammates.

Technically, Rowan Landry, the hot as hell center for the Chicago Falcons, is no longer my brother’s teammate. Or his best friend. Their college days are long behind them, and they barely talk now.

Also, I’m not dating him—we’re just sleeping together. There’s a difference.

Except there’s not a lot of sleeping going on, and neither one of us wants to stop what we’re doing.

It’s all fun and games until my brother is traded to the Falcons, because Rowan doesn’t know I’m the new goalie’s little sister. Oops.

Mr. Heartbreaker

The Perfect Blend of Humor, Heat, and Heart

The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: 💙💛💚❤️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Chemistry: 🧪🧪🧪🧪
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌏🌍
Character development: 😋🙂😁😉
Narrator(s): 🎙🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration type: Duet Narration – Full Cast

Character Background and Plot Summary

Rowan Landry is one of the star centers for the Chicago Falcons, confident on the ice but surprisingly awkward when it comes to recognizing someone from his past. Kyleigh Nilsen grew up around hockey because of her older brother, who is a hockey player. He and Rowan were friends and college teammates. When Rowan meets her years later and has absolutely no idea who she is, Kyleigh can’t resist introducing herself with the name Leigh instead Kyleigh. What starts as a harmless deception quickly turns into a fun, no strings attached hookup that becomes much more complicated once real feelings enter the picture.

I really enjoyed how the story focused on the growing connection between Rowan and Kyleigh, while the promise Kyleigh made to her late brother not to date any of his friends quietly hung over everything they shared. Watching her wrestle with that guilt while Rowan unknowingly fell harder for her made their relationship feel more layered than a typical sports romance.

Highlights and Limitations

One of my favorite moments was Rowan slowly realizing that what he thought would be a casual arrangement wasn’t enough anymore. His protectiveness and the way he began making room for Kyleigh in his everyday life felt natural instead of forced. I also loved the scenes where they teased each other over the fake name because those conversations started out funny but gradually took on more emotional weight as the truth became harder to hide.

The emotional thread involving Kyleigh’s brother added more depth than I expected. It wasn’t just about not dating a teammate of his, it was more about not telling Rowan the truth and the fact that she assumed they were just having fun and it wouldn’t last. She also wasn’t telling him about the problems she was having with the rest of her family, and he knew she was keeping secrets, but wanted her to trust him enough to talk about it.

If I had one criticism, it was that Kyleigh kept wanting to tell Rowan who she really was and who her brother was, especially after her brother gets traded to Rowan’s team, and there were so many openings when she should have told him, but she kept putting it off. Even so, I never doubted how much these two cared about each other.

Narration

This audiobook uses a full cast, and it really enhances the experience. Sean Masters and Erin Mallon do an excellent job bringing Rowan and Kyleigh to life. Sean captures Rowan’s confidence, humor, and growing vulnerability. He is becoming one of my favorite male narrators, and his deep sexy voice is the main reason. Erin gives Kyleigh warmth, wit, and enough emotional depth to make her internal conflict believable.

The supporting narrators, Connor Crais, JF Harding, Troy Duran, Teddy Hamilton, and CJ Bloom, help make the world of the Chicago Falcons feel lively and authentic. Conversations between teammates have great energy, and the different voices make it easy to keep track of everyone without ever feeling distracting. The production keeps the pacing moving, making it easy to listen for long stretches.

Final Opinion

I had a great time with Mr. Heartbreaker. The chemistry between Rowan and Kyleigh was strong from their very first meeting, but what kept me invested was how their relationship evolved once the initial attraction gave way to trust and real feelings. I found myself smiling through their banter, rooting for them when the secrets started catching up, and appreciating that both characters had understandable reasons for the choices they made.

If you enjoy hockey romances with fake identities, brother’s best friend vibes, plenty of humor, and a satisfying emotional payoff, this is an easy recommendation. It delivered the romance I wanted while giving both characters enough emotional growth to make their happily ever after feel earned.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Pinterest|BookBub



View all my reviews