How Not to Mesmerize Your Human Muse by A.K. Caggiano

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Pretending to fall might come with benefits . . . until the very end.

Kat is terrified of almost everything except demons, not since they rescued her from slavers and gave her a proper job, unspoiled food, and a consistent roof over her head. Hidden away at the post, she can’t bungle conversations or draw derision with her scarred face. But when her sister insists they flee their new untroublesome life, Kat is determined to prove they belong.

And who better to assist with belonging than a carefree demon who’s never glided into a room he didn’t immediately possess? As an adept magician from an aristocratic family, Azrion appears to have it talent, prestige, wealth. But just as the night sky changes, so does his fate—his mate breaks off their tenuous courtship, and that bodes ill for everything, including his father’s approval. The stars also brought humans to his city, and he’s convinced any one of them will inspire enough jealousy to win back his ex. If only he could predict what would come of choosing Kat.

With a contract for their fraudulent courtship in place, Kat and Azrion agree to play at being mates. It’s a risky game, but it comes with more coin than Kat can count and the promise to reclaim Azrion’s orderly life. Perhaps coin loses a bit of its shine when held beside the brilliance of a certain demon’s grin, and maybe order isn’t quite so appealing when up against the delightful peculiarities of a specific human, but actually falling for each other wasn’t part of the deal. After all, when has a deal with a demon ever gone wrong?

How Not to Mezmerize Your Human Muse

Watching Azrion Fall for Kat Was the Best Part

The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: 💙💛💚❤️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Chemistry: 🧪🧪🧪🧪
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙
World building: 🌏🌍🌎
Character development: 😋🙂😁😛
Narrator(s): 🎙🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration type: Dual Narration

Character Backgrounds and Plot Summary

The story opens with a surprisingly emotional prologue that follows Azrion as a child, always trailing after his older brother Valremont while quietly wishing he could somehow become the kind of demon who would make his constantly arguing parents love each other again. That glimpse into his childhood explains so much about why adult Azrion tries so hard to please everyone, even when he completely misses what they actually need.

Kat’s background is just as compelling. She and her sister Calypso have spent their lives surviving through theft and scams until one disastrous mistake gets them kidnapped and somehow stranded in Heck, where humans are incredibly rare. While Calypso immediately starts searching for another escape, Kat finds herself surprisingly content working in the demon postal service sorting magically delivered mail. I really liked that detail because her fascination with the lingering traces of magic in each letter made her curiosity feel genuine instead of forced.

The romance begins when Azrion visits the post office with one of the funniest requests in the book. Determined to win back his ex, Melora, he insists on sending a dozen roses one at a time instead of all together. Kat patiently helps him despite being understandably uneasy around demons and their unsettling black eyes. After that encounter, Azrion cannot stop thinking about the human clerk, and his desperate plan to hire Kat as his fake mate to make Melora jealous quickly spirals into something far more real. I loved the twist on the mate concept here. Instead of an instant magical soulmate bond, “mates” are simply couples hoping their relationship will eventually develop into a true bond, which made the fake relationship feel much more believable.

Highlights and Limitations

I am always a sucker for a fake relationship romance, and this one worked especially well because of the enormous gap between the characters. Azrion comes from one of the oldest and wealthiest demon houses, while Kat has spent most of her life wondering where her next meal would come from. Watching her navigate upper class demon society while refusing to lose herself was one of my favorite parts of the book.

I also loved how completely captivated Azrion became. His attraction never felt shallow. As he spent more time with Kat, he started seeing his own world differently because of her perspective, and I enjoyed all the little moments where he could barely stop himself from staring at her or finding excuses to touch her. Those scenes sold the romance much more than grand declarations ever could.

Kat’s lingering fear of demons also added believable tension. Even after spending time around them, she still struggled with their appearance and their magic, which made her growing trust in Azrion feel earned instead of immediate.

If I had one small criticism, it would be that I occasionally wanted the fallout with Melora to play a slightly larger role after so much attention was given to Azrion’s attempts to win her back early on. Once Kat entered the picture, I found myself far more invested in their growing relationship than the original breakup, so I would have enjoyed just a little more emotional resolution there.

Narration

Luke Persiani and Emilia Bauer made an excellent team. Emilia Bauer captured Kat’s practical nature, cautious optimism, and dry humor without making her sound overly cynical. Luke Persiani gave Azrion exactly the polished confidence I imagined from someone raised in one of Heck’s elite families. He absolutely nailed the wealthy, slightly snobbish upper crust attitude while still letting Azrion’s vulnerability come through during the quieter moments.

That said, this is purely personal preference, but I usually gravitate toward heroes with a rougher, more rugged sounding voice. Persiani’s performance fit the character perfectly, even if it was not quite my favorite style of hero narration.

Final Opinion

This was a fun paranormal romance with a fresh spin on fake dating, demon society, and the idea of mates. Even without reading the earlier books, I had no trouble following the story or becoming invested in Azrion and Kat. The magical postal service, the class differences, and Kat’s gradual adjustment to life in Heck gave the world plenty of personality beyond the romance.

Most of all, I enjoyed watching Azrion slowly realize that the woman he thought he wanted was not the one who truly understood him. His growing fascination with Kat felt natural and satisfying, and by the end I was rooting for them completely. If you enjoy fake relationship romances with humor, heart, and an unusual fantasy setting, I think this one is well worth picking up.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Pinterest|BookBub



View all my reviews