Shared by the Firemen by Cassie Cole

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I came back to Florida to settle my mother’s estate.
But after a raging house fire, I’m rescued by three swoony firemen.
There’s just one 

One of them is sorta, kinda, my ex.
Jack Franco was the boy-next-door from my childhood. Literally. Part friend, part foebut 100% swoony hunk that I always had a crush on. We spent our high school years flirting and bickering and teasing each other, but despite the way we secretly looked at each other, we went off to college and missed our chance.
Liam is Jack’s fireman teammate. From New Zealand, the yellow-haired goofball is always ready with a joke and a grin, even when the house is literally on fire.
Mateo is the third member of the team. A Cuban-American, his bronze skin and quiet demeanor make me think he’s shy. But once I get to know him? I realize he can roll up his sleeves and take-charge with the best of them.

I went on a date with Liam to make Jack jealous.
And after Mateo jumped in on the action a few days later?
Now I have my hands full in a way I never expected.

Can Jack and I work through our complicated history?
Or will our differences—and my new relationships with his friends—prove too difficult to extinguish?
SHARED BY THE FIREMEN is a sizzling Reverse Harem love story filled with action, fire, and red-hot romance. HEA guaranteed!

Rescue, Romance, and Reverse Harem

The following ratings are out of 5:
Romance: ❤️💚💙🩷
Chemistry: 🧪🧪🧪🧪
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Story/Plot: 📕📗📘📙
World building: 🌏🌍🌎🌍
Character development: 🤓😟🤯😎
Narration: 🎙🎙🎙🎙🎙
Narration Type: Dual Narration

Character Backgrounds and Plot Overview

Shared by the Firemen centers on Alyssa, a professional photographer who has built her life in New York City after a childhood spent in Georgia, then Florida. She is a practical, independent woman shaped in part by a difficult upbringing. Her mother was a woman who made no secret of the fact that she considered her twin daughters a burden, a wound that clearly left its mark on both girls even into adulthood. When their mother passes away, Alyssa travels back to Clearwater, Florida ahead of her twin sister to begin sorting through the family home. Her sister’s plan is a sensible if detached one: clean the place out and convert it into a rental property. There is no great grief here, just unfinished business.

Arriving a day early and deciding to spend the night alone in the house turns out to be an eventful choice. A fire breaks out and Alyssa is rescued by three firefighters, one of whom turns out to be Jack, a childhood neighbor who grew up just down the street. Their history is tangled and layered. They were enemies, then friends, and then something closer before it all fell apart badly enough that Jack has no desire to revisit it. The trouble is, he cannot seem to stop thinking about her. The situation becomes even more complicated when Alyssa and her sister end up renting a property that turns out to belong to Jack, neither of them having any idea of the connection when they sign on.

Liam is Jack’s closest friend, a man who originally came to the area as an international exchange student and lived with Jack’s family during their high school years before eventually settling nearby permanently. He is warm and outgoing, and when he and Alyssa begin dating, it adds a thorny new layer to her already complicated dynamic with Jack. Mateo rounds out the trio. A Cuban-American and the quietest of the three men, he is a member of the same firefighting team and their close social circle. His connection with Alyssa develops more slowly but no less meaningfully, and the story builds toward all four characters navigating a relationship that defies conventional boundaries.

Highlights & Limitations

The book’s greatest strength is the foundation it lays for the central romance through genuine backstory. The childhood history between Alyssa and Jack gives their tension real weight. It is not manufactured conflict for the sake of drama but rather the kind of complicated emotional residue that follows people who once mattered deeply to each other. That grounding makes the push and pull between them feel earned rather than arbitrary.

The Florida setting is used well. Clearwater lends the story a warmth and a slightly sun-soaked atmosphere that suits the tone, and the detail of Alyssa returning specifically to wind up her mother’s affairs adds an emotional undercurrent that keeps the story from being purely breezy. The theme of a difficult maternal relationship, handled without over-sentimentality, gives Alyssa some real depth.

The integration of all three love interests is handled with reasonable care. Liam’s backstory as a former exchange student who became part of the community is a nice touch that explains his closeness with Jack without it feeling convenient. Mateo is perhaps the least developed of the three, his quieter nature meaning he gets less page time in the early sections, though readers who appreciate a slow-burn will likely find his arc rewarding.

On the limitation side, the coincidences stack up in ways that may test patience. The rental property twist in particular requires a fair suspension of disbelief. For readers who are already fans of the reverse harem genre, this kind of contrivance tends to be forgiven as part of the conventions of the form, but those coming in without that goodwill may find it a stretch. The pacing in the middle section can also feel slightly uneven as the story juggles establishing all three romantic threads simultaneously.

Narration and Performance

The dual narration setup, with Ramona Radcliff handling Alyssa’s perspective and Julio Maxwell taking on the male characters, is a format that suits the material well. Radcliff brings a natural, relatable quality to Alyssa that makes her easy to spend time with. She handles the more emotionally layered scenes, particularly those touching on Alyssa’s relationship with her late mother, with a lightness of touch that avoids melodrama.

Maxwell differentiates the three male leads effectively, which is no small task given how much time they share scenes together. Jack’s guarded edge, Liam’s sociability, and Mateo’s quieter reserve come through as distinct rather than blending into one another. The chemistry between the two narrators in shared scenes feels organic, which is not always a given with dual narration productions. Both maintain consistent accents and energy levels throughout, making this a technically polished listen.

Final Thoughts

Shared by the Firemen is a solidly entertaining entry in the reverse harem romance genre that benefits from a stronger emotional foundation than many of its counterparts. Alyssa is a protagonist with genuine complexity, and the history she shares with Jack elevates what could have been a purely plot-driven story into something with a bit more heart. The coincidences required to keep the characters circling each other will ask something of the listener’s credulity, but the warm setting, engaging narration from both Radcliff and Maxwell, and the steady build across all three romances make for an enjoyable listen. For fans of the genre, it is a comfortable and engaging choice, and for newcomers who enjoy contemporary romance with a found-family dynamic among the male leads, it offers a reasonable entry point. It does not reinvent the wheel, but it turns it with enough charm and warmth to make the journey worthwhile.

Blog|Goodreads|Facebook|Instagram|Twitter|BookBub



View all my reviews